Support 30,000+ local farms. Members get an ad-free site, trusted reviews, and more — for $10/year.

Join for $10/year →

33705 County Rd 48, Peconic, NY 11958

Get Directions

About This Farm

In 2003, Karen and Michael Catapano, a nurse and doctor, respectively, bought a small goat farm in Mattituck. During their second year as goat farmers, they entered the American Cheese Society Annual National Competition and came in first place. Popularity ensued, and in 2005, they moved to the current farm’s location in Peconic, increasing their herd to about 100.

Own Catapano Dairy Farm?

This page already ranks on Google. Claim it to control what buyers see — edit your info, upload photos, manage products, and get a verified badge.

Claim This Farm

$50/year (or $5/month)

Our directory is built from many public sources across the internet and from farmers themselves. We work hard to keep listings accurate, but not every farm has confirmed its information with us. Farms marked Verified manage their own listing and have confirmed their details. Own a farm? Verify your listing →

Farms Near Catapano Dairy Farm

Common Questions About Catapano Dairy Farm

Where is Catapano Dairy Farm located?

Catapano Dairy Farm is at 33705 County Rd 48, Peconic, NY 11958, Peconic, New York. The map on this page has directions.

What does Catapano Dairy Farm sell?

Dairy Farm. Availability changes with the season, so call ahead for anything specific.

How do I contact Catapano Dairy Farm?

Call 631-765-8042, or visit http://www.catapanodairyfarm.com/.

Reviews & Comments (0)

Written by members only — the $10/yr keeps reviews honest, with no bots or fake ratings.

Sign in and become a member to leave a review.

No reviews yet — members, be the first to share your experience.